Saturday, February 6, 2021

ECG Blog #191 (ECG MP-8) — Is AV Block Complete? (3rd Degree vs AV Dissociation)

The 2-lead rhythm strip shown in Figure-1 was obtained from an elderly woman who presented to the ED following a syncopal episode. On the basis of this rhythm strip — she was diagnosed as being in complete AV Block.

  • Question #1Is there AV Dissociation in Figure-1?
  • Question #2: Do YOU agree that the rhythm shown in this figure represents complete ( = 3rd-degree) AV Block?

  • Extra Credit: Why do I suspect that a majority of those reading this post will get the answer to Question #2 wrong?


Figure-1: This 2-lead rhythm strip was obtained from an elderly woman with syncope. Do YOU agree that this rhythm represents complete AV block?  (See text).


What were YOUR Answers?

  • Your Answer to Question #1 —

  • Your Answer to Question #2 —




NOTE: Some readers may prefer at this point to watch today's ECG Media Pearl #8 before moving on to my final interpretation. That said — Feel free at any time to review my My Thoughts on ECG #1 (that appear just below ECG MP-8).


Today’s ECG Media PEARL #8 (8:20 minutes Video) — is an ECG video that reviews the difference between AV Dissociation vs Complete AV Block — and illustrates this difference while explaining the interpretation of the rhythm in Figure-1.



MY Thoughts on the Rhythm in Figure-1:

Note that the above ECG Media PEARL #8 reviews interpretation of the rhythm in Figure-1 in detail. For clarity — I reproduce below selected KEY figures from this video.

  • We see a total of only 5 beats in Figure-1. The ventricular rhythm is regular at a rate just under 50/minute. It is difficult to assess QRS duration from just these 2 leads — but it looks like there may be slight QRS widening (at the least, we see a multiphasic QRS complex in lead V1).
  • The atrial rhythm is fairly regular at a rate of ~100-110/minute (RED arrows highlighting P waves that we are certain about). Use of calipers tells us to expect another P wave at the spot highlighted by the PINK arrow (Figure-2). So, given the overall regular appearance of the 10 other P waves in this tracing (RED arrows) — we can be almost certain that P wave regularity continues, even though 1 P wave is hidden by simultaneous occurrence of the QRS complex of beat #3.


Figure-2: I’ve added RED arrows to Figure-1 to indicate P waves were are certain about. Given the overall regularity of the P wave rhythm — we strongly suspect another P wave is hiding within the QRS complex of beat #3 (PINK arrow).



MY Thoughts on the Rhythm (Continued):

By the systematic Ps, Qs & 3R Approach to rhythm interpretation (which we discussed in detail in ECG Blog #185) — the remaining parameter not yet assessed in Figure-2 is the 3rd “R” = Are P waves Related (ie, “married” ) to neighboring QRS complexes?

  • The easiest way to assess if P waves are related to neighboring QRS complexes — is to look in front of each QRS complex — and see if the PR interval stays the same or constantly changes.
  • In Figure-2 — it should be readily apparent that the PR interval in front of each of the 5 QRS complexes is never the same. 
  • PEARL #1: To emphasize — that although the PR intervals that precede beat #1 and beat #2 look similar — use of calipers immediately shows that the PR interval preceding beat #2 is longer. Calipers also immediately show that the PR interval preceding beat #3 is longer than the PR interval preceding beat #2. Thus, the PR intervals in Figure-2 are constantly changing.

Putting This Together: In Figure-2 — there is a slightly widened QRS complex with a regular ventricular rhythm (at just under 50/minute) — a fairly regular atrial rhythm (at ~100-110/minute) — and — a PR interval before each of the 5 QRS complexes that constantly changes!

  • Therefore — there is complete AV Dissociation for the 5-beat (6.4-second duration) rhythm strip shown in Figure-2 — because none of the P waves are being conducted to the ventricles.
  • PEARL #2: Although there is complete AV dissociation for this 5-beat rhythm strip in Figure-2 — we have not proved that there is complete AV block. Often ignored by many clinicians is the all-important criterion for complete AV block that requires the rhythm strip to be long enough — and — the rhythm to be slow enough for P waves to occur in all phases of the cardiac cycle, yet still fail to conduct. That is, before you can prove the presence of complete AV block — you have to demonstrate that P waves have adequate opportunity to conduct (by occurring in all parts of the R-R interval) — yet still fail to do so. The 6.4-second rhythm strip in Figure-2 is unfortunately just too short to guarantee that there has been adequate opportunity for this to occur.
  • As to the interpretation of this rhythm — although we have not proved the presence of complete AV block — there at the least appears to be significant 2nd-Degree AV Block — because we would normally expect the P waves occurring near the middle of each R-R interval to conduct, yet there is no evidence of any conduction (ie, no QRS complex follows closely after any of these P waves).


The Case Continues: In Figure-3 — the next 4 beats that come after beat #5 are now shown.

  • Do YOU still think complete AV block is present?


Figure-3: The rhythm from Figure-2 is continued — and the next 4 beats are shown. Is there still complete AV dissociation?

What do YOU Think?

  • In Figure-3 — Is there still complete AV dissociation?


MY Thoughts on Figure-3:

A number of changes are evident in Figure-3, now that we have seen the next 4 beats in the tracing.

  • Note that the QRS complex narrows and changes in morphology for the last 4 beats in Figure-3.
  • Regular P waves continue throughout the entire tracing. Yet as opposed to what we saw with the shorter (5-beat) tracing in Figure-2 — the PR interval preceding beats #6, 7, 8 and 9 in Figure-3 now appears to be constant! This tells us that beats #6, 7, 8 and 9 are sinus conducted — which confirms that the rhythm in Figure-2 was not complete AV block, because when P waves finally have an opportunity to conduct, they do!
  • These last 4 beats in the rhythm strip also confirm the conduction defect as a form of 2nd-Degree AV Block, in which there is 2:1 AV conduction.  


PEARL #3: I emphasized in the above ECG Media Pearl #8 — the difference between complete AV block vs AV dissociation without complete AV block. The KEY for making this distinction, is to look for evidence of conduction:

  • The fact that the PR interval preceding beats #6, 7, 8 and 9 remains the same tells us that these beats are sinus conducted!
  • Sinus conduction is further supported by narrowing of the QRS complex (with a change in QRS morphology) for these last 4 beats in Figure-3.
  • NOTE: Most of the time with complete AV block — the ventricular rhythm will be regular. This is because escape rhythms are in general regular. Although extremely subtle in Figure-3 (You will need calipers to verify this!) — the R-R interval preceding beat #6 is ever-so-slightly shorter than the R-R interval preceding each of the prior 5 beats in this tracing. Recognition in a tracing with AV dissociation that a beat occurs earlier-than-expected is an excellent clue that the reason this beat occurs slightly earlier is that it is being conducted!

PEARL #4: To clarify the difference between AV dissociation vs complete AV block — I’ve added an ADDENDUM to this post in which I reproduce a 7-page excerpt from my ACLS-2013 Arrhythmias (Expanded Version) book. Among the KEY “take home” points in this excerpt are the following:

  • The term, “AV dissociation” — simply means that for a certain period of time, sinus P waves are not related to neighboring QRS complexes. That is, P waves preceding the QRS are not being conducted to the ventricles.
  • AV dissociation may be as short-lived as occurring for 1 or 2 beats — or, it may be persistent as occurs with complete AV block. 
  • AV dissociation is never a “diagnosis”. Instead — it is a condition cause by “something else”. The task for the clinician is to figure out what the cause of AV dissociation is for any given rhythm. There are 3 possible causes: i) AV block itself (either from 2nd- or 3rd -degree AV block); ii) Usurpation — in which P waves transiently do not conduct because an accelerated junctional or ventricular rhythm takes over the pacemaking function (ie, “usurps” the rhythm); and/oriii) Default — in which a junctional or ventricular escape rhythm takes over by “default”, because the rate of the sinus pacemaker has slowed down for whatever reason. 


Laddergram Illustration:

To better illustrate the mechanism of the 9-beat rhythm we see in Figure-3 — I’ve drawn a laddergram (Figure-4):

  • A fairly regular atrial rhythm is seen throughout the tracing (RED arrows).
  • There is complete AV dissociation for the first 5 beats in the tracing — because none of the P waves during this initial part of the rhythm are conducted to the ventricles. 
  • It is difficult to be certain from where in the ventricles the escape rhythm arises during these first 5 beats (ie, could be from the ventricles, or from one of the hemifascicles or bundle branches) — but the escape rhythm almost certainly arises from below the AV node.
  • The P wave preceding beat #6 is conducted! Note that the PR interval preceding beats #7, 8 and 9 is the same as the PR interval preceding beat #6, because all 4 of these beats are conducted.
  • There is 2nd-Degree AV Block, with 2:1 AV conduction for these last 4 beats on the tracing. 
  • The reason for AV dissociation in Figure-4 during the initial part of the tracing is 2nd-Degree AV Block. It is impossible to be certain from this single rhythm strip, whether this represents Mobitz I or Mobitz II 2nd-degree AV block — because we never see 2 conducted P waves in a row (so we don’t know if the PR interval would progressively increase IF given a chance to do so).
  • Beyond-the-Core: We also can not tell whether or not this rhythm represents a form of “high-grade” 2nd-degree AV block — because we never see 2 P waves in a row that should conduct yet fail to do so during the early portion of this rhythm strip in which there is complete AV dissociation.
  • P.S.: For those wanting review on how to read (and/or draw) laddergrams — Please CHECK OUT my ECG Blog #188.

Figure-4: Laddergram illustration of the mechanism for the 9-beat rhythm strip shown in Figure-3.

  • What follows below is a 7-page excerpt from my ACLS-2013 Arrhythmias (Expanded Version) book, in which I review the distinction between AV dissociation vs complete AV block.

No comments:

Post a Comment